We're All Experts Now: A Security Case Against Security Detention
19 Pages Posted: 15 Jul 2008
Abstract
While a range of U.S. and international law scholars have criticized the United States' current approach to counterterrorism detention operations, some of the same voices are now recommending the development of a more formally sanctioned 'preventive' regime for detaining terrorist suspects. With a view both to resolving current dilemmas like the status of detainees held at the U.S. Naval Base at Guantanamo Bay, and to meeting the anticipated ongoing security interests of the United States, scholars like Jack Goldsmith, Robert Chesney, and others have emphasized the legitimate national interest in the "preventive incapacitation of uniformless terrorists who have the capacity to inflict mass casualties and enormous economic harms and who thus must be stopped before they act." And indeed, neither U.S. nor international law imposes a categorical prohibition against states' depriving individuals of their liberty for reasons other than their having committing a criminal offense. Yet even if it were possible to construct a preventive detention regime for terrorist suspects that satisfies U.S. and international procedural requirements, this essay suggests that it is not at all clear such a scheme would advance the security interests its proponents identify. Ultimately, as this essay explores, legal scholarship's current attraction to 'preventive' detention hinges as much or more on questions of national security policy than on questions of law.
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Paper statistics
Recommended Papers
-
The Mosaic Theory, National Security, and the Freedom of Information Act
By David Pozen
-
By Craig Forcese and Lorne Waldman
-
By Kent Roach
-
The Criminal Law and Terrorism
By Kent Roach
-
International Human Rights Law and Security Detention
By Doug Cassel
-
Out of the Shadows: Preventive Detention, Suspected Terrorists, and War
By David Cole
-
Canada’s National Security 'Complex' - Assessing the Secrecy Rules
-
Catch and Release: A Role for Preventive Detention Without Charge in Canadian Anti-Terrorism Law
