Happiness and Punishment
University of Chicago Law Review, Vol. 76, 2009
U of Chicago Law & Economics, Olin Working Paper No. 424
U of Chicago, Public Law and Legal Theory Working Paper No. 230
U Illinois Law & Economics Research Paper No. LE08-029
Chicago-Kent Intellectual Property, Science & Technology Research Paper No. 10-024
48 Pages Posted: 22 Aug 2008 Last revised: 19 Jan 2010
Abstract
This article continues our project to apply groundbreaking new literature on the behavioral psychology of human happiness to some of the most deeply analyzed questions in law. Here we explain that the new psychological understandings of happiness interact in startling ways with the leading theories of criminal punishment. Punishment theorists, both retributivist and utilitarian, have failed to account for human beings' ability to adapt to changed circumstances, including fines and (surprisingly) imprisonment. At the same time, these theorists have largely ignored the severe hedonic losses brought about by the post-prison social and economic deprivations (unemployment, divorce, and disease) caused by even short periods of incarceration. These twin phenomena significantly disrupt efforts to attain proportionality between crime and punishment and to achieve effective marginal deterrence. Hedonic psychology thus threatens to upend conventional conceptions of punishment and requires retributivists and utilitarians to find novel methods of calibrating traditional punitive sanctions if they are to maintain the foundations upon which punishment theory rests.
Keywords: punishment, utilitarian, retributivist, happiness, prison, health, deterrence, unemployment
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
Behavioral Criminal Law and Economics
By Richard H. Mcadams and Thomas S. Ulen
-
Hyperbolic Criminals and Repeated Time-Inconsistent Misconduct
-
Behavioral Economics, Neurophysiology, Addiction and the Law
-
Resident Perceptions of Crime: How Similar are They to Official Crime Rates?
By John R. Hipp
-
Reconsidering the Relationship between Cognitive Psychology and Plea Bargaining
-
Uncertainty Revisited: Legal Prediction and Legal Postdiction
By Alon Harel and Ehud Guttel