The Information Systems Profession: Myth or Reality?

Abstract

Much of the prior research into information systems (IS) workers hasassumed that they are professionals. In this paper we examine thecharacteristics of IS workers, IS work and the IS workplace, and suggest thatthis perspective is mistaken. Drawing on the sociological theory of professionsas a reference discipline we contend that IS professionalism is aninappropriate categorization, and that such a portrayal limits ourunderstanding of IS workers and their work.We argue in this paper that a more faithful and potentially usefulcharacterization is to view IS workers as members of an occupational group.Within this perspective, an understanding of the occupational culture, contextand history of IS workers is essential to an understanding of the ISoccupation. We examine and challenge some common myths regarding ISwork, technology and the IS workplace. We conclude by making somerecommendations for future research are provided, which should enhance ourunderstanding of IS workers as members of an occupation.