Download this Paper Open PDF in Browser

The Philosopher's Brief

Constitutional Commentary, Forthcoming

U of Alabama Public Law Research Paper No. 1298035

11 Pages Posted: 9 Nov 2008  

Paul Horwitz

University of Alabama School of Law

Date Written: November 8, 2008

Abstract

This is a short commentary on Kent Greenawalt's recent major contribution to law and religion, the two-volume work Religion and the Constitution, stemming from a roundtable discussion of his work at Notre Dame Law School.

This commentary makes two arguments about Religion and the Constitution. First, it questions whether the "bottom-up" approach that Greenawalt advocates for law and religion questions can succeed absent an explicit theory of the Religion Clauses. Greenawalt proceeds in the careful fashion of a legal philosopher, setting out a range of values that underlie the Religion Clauses and offering a sensitive case-by-case examination of various Religion Clause issues. It is a philosopher's brief for the Religion Clauses, as it were. But it lacks a clear philosophy: it does not ultimately tell us how to rank and reconcile competing Religion Clauses values. Such a philosophy may, in fact, ultimately be unattainable. But without it, we are left without clear standards for evaluating the "reasonableness" of Greenawalt's conclusions in particular cases.

Second, it argues that Greenawalt's work may be insufficiently attentive to the institutional nature of religious institutions and their role in the social and constitutional constellation. An alternative "bottom-up" method, rather than attempting to reconcile abstract Religion Clause values, might instead proceed by considering the role, practices, and capacity for self-regulation of various religious entities at an institutional level, and considering the legal implications of such an approach.

Keywords: greenawalt, law and religion

Suggested Citation

Horwitz, Paul, The Philosopher's Brief (November 8, 2008). Constitutional Commentary, Forthcoming; U of Alabama Public Law Research Paper No. 1298035. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1298035

Paul Horwitz (Contact Author)

University of Alabama School of Law ( email )

P.O. Box 870382
Tuscaloosa, AL 35487
United States

Paper statistics

Downloads
107
Rank
218,011
Abstract Views
1,295