Evidence for Homeschooling: Constitutional Analysis in Light of Social Science Research

36 Pages Posted: 19 Dec 2008 Last revised: 29 Dec 2008

Tanya K. Dumas

affiliation not provided to SSRN

Sean Gates

Charis Lex P.C.

Deborah Schwarzer

HomeSchool Association of California; GCA Law Partners LLP; Gifted Homeschoolers Forum

Date Written: December 17, 2008

Abstract

Homeschooling is a time-honored and widespread practice. It often presents, however, a conflict between the constitutional right of parents to direct the education of their children and the State's right to impose regulations in the interest of ensuring an educated citizenry. The Supreme Court has made it clear that any regulation impacting this constitutional right must be "reasonable." The courts have therefore generally resolved homeschooling cases by examining whether state regulation of homeschooling places an unreasonable burden on the rights of parents. The courts, however, have altogether failed to address another, more fundamental question: whether the state regulation in fact advances the State interest. A regulation that fails this criterion cannot be "reasonable." Using the vehicle of a recent California appellate court case, in which the court initially upheld a regulation prohibiting parents from homeschooling their children unless they first obtained a state teaching credential, we show how recent social science research should impact the analysis. Instead of assuming away the issue of whether the regulation in fact advances the State interest, we show that this type of empirical research will allow courts to be able to answer this threshold question.

Keywords: homeschooling, education, constitutional rights, parents, parental rights, reasonable regulation, compulsory education

Suggested Citation

Dumas, Tanya K. and Gates, Sean and Schwarzer, Deborah, Evidence for Homeschooling: Constitutional Analysis in Light of Social Science Research (December 17, 2008). Widener Law Review, Forthcoming. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1317439

Tanya K. Dumas

affiliation not provided to SSRN

Sean Gates (Contact Author)

Charis Lex P.C. ( email )

United States

HOME PAGE: http://www.charislex.com

Deborah Schwarzer

HomeSchool Association of California ( email )

P.O. Box 77873
Corona, CA 92877
United States
888-472-4440 (Phone)
650-475-8444 (Fax)

HOME PAGE: http://www.hsc.org

GCA Law Partners LLP ( email )

1891 Landings Drive
Mountain View, CA 94087
United States
650-428-3900 (Phone)
650-428-3901 (Fax)

HOME PAGE: http://www.gcalaw.com

Gifted Homeschoolers Forum ( email )

P.O. Box 18865
San Jose, CA 95158
United States
612-435-4726 (Phone)
650-475-8444 (Fax)

HOME PAGE: http://giftedhomeschoolers.org

Paper statistics

Downloads
1,520
Rank
8,667
Abstract Views
9,076