Combining Imprecise or Conflicting Probability Judgments: A Choice-Based Study
48 Pages Posted: 6 Mar 2009 Last revised: 15 Jul 2009
Date Written: March 3, 2009
Abstract
This article develops a new approach to study the impact on beliefs and decisions of uncertain probability forecasts by advisors. The core concept of that approach, which builds on the revealed-preference approach favored by economists, is the one of revealed beliefs - the precise probability leading to the same choice as an uncertain probability forecast. The paper defines two properties of revealed beliefs - pessimism and likelihood sensibility - and allows them to vary as a function of the source of uncertainty. It then focuses on the impacts on revealed beliefs of two uncertain contexts of intense practical importance, namely consensual but imprecise uncertainty (Si) and conflicting uncertainty (Sc). In the first case, the advisors agree on the same imprecise probability forecast whereas in the latter case the advisors disagree on the probability of the same risk and the decision-makers receives two precise but different probability forecasts. Two experiments test a series of predictions concerning the impacts on revealed beliefs of each uncertain context. The results of both studies show that revealed beliefs vary as a function of the source of uncertainty, in particular for low and high probability events. The second study tests a series of predictions on the differences between revealed beliefs and the beliefs that decision-makers report as their best estimate of the probability of the risk (called judged beliefs).
Keywords: sources of uncertainty, beliefs, experts, aggregation, cumulative prospect theory
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
On the Intuition of Rank-Dependent Utility
By Enrico Diecidue and Peter P. Wakker
-
Aspiration Level, Probability of Success and Failure, and Expected Utility
By Enrico Diecidue and Jeroen Van De Ven
-
Seeing the Forest When Entry is Unlikely: Probability and the Mental Representation of Events
By Cheryl J. Wakslak, Yaacov Trope, ...
-
Comonotonic Independence: The Critical Test between Classical and Rank-Dependent Utility Theories
By Peter P. Wakker, Ido Erev, ...
-
Valuing Money and Things: Why a $20 Item Can be Worth More and Less than $20
By A. Peter Mcgraw, Eldar Shafir, ...
-
By Laure Cabantous, Denis Hilton, ...
-
Representation Over Time: The Effects of Temporal Distance on Similarity
By Daniel M. Bartels and Samuel B Day