The Supreme Court's Misleading Footnote in General Dynamics

11 Pages Posted: 7 Mar 2009

See all articles by Erik M. Jensen

Erik M. Jensen

Case Western Reserve University School of Law

Abstract

This article examines footnote 3 in the Supreme Court's 1987 opinion in United States v. General Dynamics. In that case, governed by the law in place before the Tax Reform Act of 1984, the Court held that General Dynamics had to defer deductions attributable to claims for employee medical expenses until the claims were approved. In the footnote, the Court suggested that the 1984 amendment to section 461(h) of the Internal Revenue Code postponing the time for deducting accrued expenses until economic performance would, in a similar case governed by the statutory change, have further deferred General Dynamics' deduction until time of payment. The author argues that the Court was wrong as a general matter (even though its suggestion might accidentally lead to the right timing result in some cases). He argues that the Court misread the legislative history of section 461(h) and provided no theoretical justification for treating economic performance as occurring at time of payment (rather than when services are provided) in the case of "employee benefit liabilities." Moreover, the Court ignored the potential effects of other sections of the Code, such as section 404, which might control the timing of deductions associated with deferred benefits provided through unfunded medical reimbursement plans.

Keywords: Taxation, United States v. General Dynamics, Deductions, IRC section 461(h), IRC section 404, Employee Medical Expenses

JEL Classification: K34

Suggested Citation

Jensen, Erik M., The Supreme Court's Misleading Footnote in General Dynamics. Tax Notes, Vol. 41, p. 665, 1988. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1354825

Erik M. Jensen (Contact Author)

Case Western Reserve University School of Law ( email )

11075 East Boulevard
Cleveland, OH 44106-7148
United States
216-368-3613 (Phone)
216-368-2086 (Fax)

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
36
Abstract Views
487
PlumX Metrics