Norm Conflict in International Law: Whither Human Rights?
79 Pages Posted: 3 Apr 2009
Date Written: April 2, 2009
The article examines norm conflicts, defined as situations where one norm constitutes, has led to, or may lead to a breach of another, and particularly those norm conflicts in which one of the conflicting norms is a rule of human rights law. Such instances occur more and more every day, are increasingly litigated, and can be of great political importance. For example, a human rights treaty might prohibit the preventative detention or internment of persons under any circumstances, while the UN Security Council might pass a resolution actually authorizing such detention, say in relation to suspected terrorists. What does then happen when a state's obligations under a human rights treaty conflict with its obligations under the UN Charter?
In that regard, one possible solution is that pursuant to Article 103 of the UN Charter, obligations under the Charter - including binding Security Council resolutions - prevail over conflicting treaty obligations of the UN member states. The article will explore whether the Council can displace international human rights treaties, and if so, how can such a development be curtailed or avoided. It will elaborate on various forms of norm conflict resolution and avoidance, and will discuss the recent jurisprudence of the House of Lords (Al-Jedda), the European Court of Human Rights (Behrami and Bosphorus) and the courts of the European Union (Kadi). The article thus provides a systematic overview of the impact of norm conflicts on the protection of human rights in a fragmented international legal order.
Keywords: international law, norm conflict, human rights, fragmentation, Behrami, Al-Jedda, Kadi, Bosphorus
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
The UN Security Council and the Rule of Law
Jurisdiction and International Responsibility in Peace Support Operations: The Behrami and Saramati Cases
By Aurel Sari
The House of Lords in Al-Jedda and Public International Law: Attribution of Conduct to UN-Authorized Forces and the Power of the Security Council to Displace Human Rights
Breaches of the European Convention on Human Rights Resulting from the Conduct of International Organisations
Taking Stock: The UN Security Council and the Rule of Law
Approaches to Resolving Growing Conflicts between Human Rights and International Law Norms in British and European Courts