Efficient Committed Budget for Implementing Target Audit Probability for Many Inspectees
Management Science, 2009 55:12, 2000-2018. doi:10.1287/mnsc.1090.1083
46 Pages Posted: 10 May 2009 Last revised: 10 Dec 2020
Date Written: August 1, 2009
Strategic models of auditor-inspectee interaction have neglected implementation details in multiple-inspectee settings. With multiple inspectees, the target audit probability derived from the standard analysis can be implemented with sampling plans differing in the budgets committed to support them. Overly-committed audit budgets tie up unneeded resources that could have been allocated for better uses. This paper studies the minimum committed budget required to implement a target audit probability when (i) the audit sample can be contingent on “red flags” due to signals of inspectees’ private information (e.g., from self-reporting) and (ii) the number of inspectees is large. It proposes an audit rule called bounded simple random sampling (SRS), which is shown to require no more committed budget to support than two other rules naturally generalized from the one-to-one analysis. When the number of inspectees is large enough, bounded SRS is nearly as good as any efficient audit rule, which demands the lowest committed budget necessary to implement the target audit probability. The results offer insights on how audit sampling plans may be formulated to reduce inefficiency and what budget usage ratios should be expected accordingly.
Keywords: Audit sampling plan, audit budget, tax audit, tax compliance, tax evasion, inspection game, appropriation and rescission
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation