Footnotes (245)



The Constitutional Life of Legislative Instructions in America

Christopher Terranova

New York University School of Law

May 12, 2009

New York University Law Review, Vol. 84, p. 1331, 2009

In America's early history, state legislatures often formally instructed their federal representatives on particular votes. This practice flourished for a century, but then died out - a change that many scholars attribute to the Seventeenth Amendment. This Note argues that previous scholars have ignored other, more important reasons for the demise of instructions.

The six-year term length for United States senators, combined with the increasingly rapid turnover in state legislatures, prevented binding instructions from becoming entrenched. Instructions were held in place only by constitutional culture, but even this did not last. After Southern Democrats vigorously used the practice to purge Whigs from the Senate, instructions were indelibly linked to the South. Not surprisingly, the doctrine of instructions was one of the casualties of the Civil War. The roles had been reversed: Now the states - especially the Southern states - were taking instructions from the federal government. Today, instructions still exist, but as nonbinding "requests" for action. This new conception of instructions returns us full circle, to James Madison's conception of the proper role of instructions: A right of "the people . . . to express and communicate their wishes" to their representatives.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 44

Keywords: constitution, history, representation, Senate, instructions, Seventeenth Amendment, political safeguards of federalism

Open PDF in Browser Download This Paper

Date posted: May 18, 2009 ; Last revised: November 16, 2009

Suggested Citation

Terranova, Christopher, The Constitutional Life of Legislative Instructions in America (May 12, 2009). New York University Law Review, Vol. 84, p. 1331, 2009. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1403685

Contact Information

Christopher Terranova (Contact Author)
New York University School of Law ( email )
40 Washington Square South
New York, NY 10012-1099
United States

Feedback to SSRN

Paper statistics
Abstract Views: 528
Downloads: 50
Footnotes:  245