The Rule of Law is Dead! Long Live the Rule of Law!

42 Pages Posted: 14 May 2009

See all articles by Keith J. Bybee

Keith J. Bybee

Syracuse University - College of Law; Syracuse University - Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs

Date Written: March 27, 2009

Abstract

Polls show that a significant proportion of the public considers judges to be political. This result holds whether Americans are asked about Supreme Court justices, federal judges, state judges, or judges in general. At the same time, a large majority of the public also believes that judges are fair and impartial arbiters, and this belief also applies across the board. In this paper, I consider what this half-law-half-politics understanding of the courts means for judicial legitimacy and the public confidence on which that legitimacy rests. Drawing on the Legal Realists, and particularly on the work of Thurman Arnold, I argue against the notion that the contradictory views must be resolved in order for judicial legitimacy to remain intact. A rule of law built on contending legal and political beliefs is not necessarily fair or just. But it can be stable. At least in the context of law and courts, a house divided may stand.

This paper was prepared for presentation at the “What’s Law Got to Do With It?” Conference, Indiana University School of Law – Bloomington, March 27-28, 2009. Please do not cite or quote without permission. The author thanks Ellen Palminteri and Kyle Somers for their valuable research assistance.

Keywords: Judicial Legitimacy, Public Opinion, Legal Realism, Thurman Arnold

Suggested Citation

Bybee, Keith James, The Rule of Law is Dead! Long Live the Rule of Law! (March 27, 2009). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1404600 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1404600

Keith James Bybee (Contact Author)

Syracuse University - College of Law ( email )

321 Eggers Hall
Syracuse University
Syracuse, NY 13244-1030
United States
315-443-9743 (Phone)

Syracuse University - Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs ( email )

400 Eggers Hall
Syracuse, NY 13244
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
301
Abstract Views
1,096
rank
123,255
PlumX Metrics