Holism About Neurological Representation: A Primer, with Applications to Law and Morality

Posted: 16 May 2009

See all articles by William Casebeer

William Casebeer

United States Air Force - Joint Warfare Analysis Center

Date Written: May 18, 2009

Abstract

What does it mean for brains to represent things? A brief review of the history of how philosophers and cognitive scientists have approached the problem of mental representation will serve as a stalking horse for the position I will present neurobiological evidence for: holism. Brains perform a mapping function, identifying salient features of the world by way of conceptual superstructures which link perceptions to action. This position gives us some clues as to where "law" and "morality" will be represented in the brain: in high-order state spaces containing what is salient for canonical legal and moral emotions and judgments. While some commonalities at the core of legal and moral situations (such as their social nature, their relationship to the common welfare, and to ideas about contract and consent) will drive localization of representation, what is salient will change from circumstance to circumstance, meaning moral and legal representations will generally be highly distributed in the brain. At the end of cognitive neurobiology's golden age, we should not expect to see anything like a "moral module," but instead a suite of faculties well-suited to allow evolved rational social animals a fighting chance to flourish in complex moral and legal environments.

Suggested Citation

Casebeer, William, Holism About Neurological Representation: A Primer, with Applications to Law and Morality (May 18, 2009). Gruter Institute Squaw Valley Conference 2009: Law, Behavior & the Brain, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1405285

William Casebeer (Contact Author)

United States Air Force - Joint Warfare Analysis Center ( email )

7170 Kitchen Drive
King George, VA 22485
United States

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
331
PlumX Metrics