Continued DOJ Oversight of the Google Book Search Settlement: Defending Our Public Values and Protecting Competition

45 Pages Posted: 27 May 2009 Last revised: 26 Oct 2012

Christopher A. Suarez

Yale University - Law School

Date Written: May 25, 2009

Abstract

As it undertook its massive book digitization project, Google drew the ire of authors and publishers when it began scanning thousands of copyrighted books without authorization. Authors and publishers filed a class action lawsuit that challenged Google’s fair use of their copyrighted works, and the parties subsequently agreed to a comprehensive settlement. While this settlement has many provisions that promote the public interest goals of access to knowledge and technological innovation, many other provisions raise antitrust concerns. The settlement establishes a market with high barriers to entry and promotes a court-sanctioned monopoly in the market for searchable, digitized books. Because the public interest values implicated by this settlement are substantial, this Article argues that the DOJ needs to proactively intervene to ensure that the settlement is narrowly tailored to promote competition in the market for searchable, digitized books. It is likely that the settlement will be agreed to in its current form. A proactive stance by the DOJ can help to mitigate anticompetitive concerns. Additionally, such a stance will ensure that both the DOJ and the public have adequate opportunities to reflect on the future of digital books and the public interests that are at stake. While the DOJ has recently begun an antitrust inquiry into the settlement and has expressed some antitrust concerns in a court filing, its inquiry must be a vigorous, thorough analysis of the settlement’s antitrust implications. The settlement’s hasty approval could prove costly, and DOJ antitrust oversight should be maintained if the settlement is approved.

Keywords: Google Book Search Settlement, antitrust, competition, digital libraries

Suggested Citation

Suarez, Christopher A., Continued DOJ Oversight of the Google Book Search Settlement: Defending Our Public Values and Protecting Competition (May 25, 2009). New York Law School Law Review, Vol. 53, 2010/11. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1409824

Christopher Alan Suarez (Contact Author)

Yale University - Law School ( email )

P.O. Box 208215
New Haven, CT 06520-8215
United States

Paper statistics

Downloads
354
Rank
67,799
Abstract Views
3,621