Download this Paper Open PDF in Browser

Of Wrongful Birth, Wrongful Life, Comparative Law and the Politics of Tort Law Systems

Tydskrif vir Heedendaagse Romeins-Hollandse Reg (THRHR), Vol. 72, p. 257, 2009

17 Pages Posted: 25 Jun 2009 Last revised: 2 Apr 2013

Ivo Giesen

Utrecht Centre for Accountability and Liability Law; Utrecht University School of Law (the Netherlands)

Date Written: June 24, 2009

Abstract

In analysing ‘wrongful birth’ and ‘wrongful life’ cases, comparative law is used extensively. This article examines those claims in light of the Dutch Kelly case and the recent South African decision in Stewart v Botha. I argue first that the right to self-determination and the sanctioning of a breach of that fundamental right are at stake here and that those considerations point towards allowing these claims. However, it is also argued that it is not so much the outcomes and arguments found elsewhere through comparative law that are decisive in highly debated cases like those concerning wrongful birth and wrongful life, but that instead it is the cultural background, the policies within a tort law system that decides the issue, irrespective of how the legal comparative arguments are being weighed.

Keywords: wrongful life, wrongful birth, comparative law, legal policy, tort law, self-determination

JEL Classification: K13, K32, I18

Suggested Citation

Giesen, Ivo, Of Wrongful Birth, Wrongful Life, Comparative Law and the Politics of Tort Law Systems (June 24, 2009). Tydskrif vir Heedendaagse Romeins-Hollandse Reg (THRHR), Vol. 72, p. 257, 2009. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1424901

Ivo Giesen (Contact Author)

Utrecht Centre for Accountability and Liability Law ( email )

Janskerkhof 12
Utrecht, 3512 BL
Netherlands
0031302536148 (Phone)

HOME PAGE: http://www.uu.nl/NL/FACULTEITEN/REBO/ORGANISATIE/DEPARTEMENTEN/DEPARTEMENTRECHTSGELEERDHEID/Pages/de

Utrecht University School of Law (the Netherlands) ( email )

3508 TC Utrecht
Utrecht
Netherlands

Paper statistics

Downloads
1,149
Rank
14,086
Abstract Views
3,774