Palsgraf, Principles of Tort Law, and the Persistent Need for Common-Law Judgment, Perhaps Even on IP Infringement

Akron Intellectual Property Journal, 2009

U of Akron Legal Studies Research Paper 09-07

17 Pages Posted: 25 Jun 2009 Last revised: 12 Aug 2009

Jay Dratler Jr.

University of Akron - School of Law

Date Written: June 25, 2009

Abstract

This short paper explains how two time-honored principles of tort law - proximate cause and culpability - might clarify and rationalize the law of secondary liability for intellectual-property (IP) infringement. It begins by analyzing how Judge Cardozo’s classic opinion in Palsgraf used these principles to chart an intermediate course between intentional and strict liability. It then seeks to apply the same approach to IP cases, in which direct liability is strict, but secondary liability involves culpability. Using the recent cases of Tiffany v. eBay and Perfect 10 v. VISA as examples, it analyzes how these principles might apply, respectively, to an on-line auctioneer’s secondary liability for third parties’ sales of counterfeits and a credit-card service’s secondary liability for Internet sales of infringing images. In the process, it suggests that reverting to tort-law basics could simplify and shorten both analyses and judicial opinions in IP cases and perhaps produce more sensible results, in part by introducing economic principles like the least-cost avoider. It concludes with some observations about the recent progress in federal-common-law analysis of other IP issues and its potential to revivify an increasingly rigid and formalistic approach to fields of law outside IP.

Keywords: copyright, secondary liability, vicarious liability, contributory infringement, inducement, intellectual property, IP, tort, Palsgraf, proximate cause, culability

JEL Classification: A12, K13, K29, K42, O34

Suggested Citation

Dratler, Jay, Palsgraf, Principles of Tort Law, and the Persistent Need for Common-Law Judgment, Perhaps Even on IP Infringement (June 25, 2009). Akron Intellectual Property Journal, 2009; U of Akron Legal Studies Research Paper 09-07. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1425691

Jay Dratler Jr. (Contact Author)

University of Akron - School of Law ( email )

150 University Ave.
Akron, OH 44325-2901
United States

Paper statistics

Downloads
108
Rank
208,651
Abstract Views
889