The Reliability of an Instrument
Marcel J. Boumans
Utrecht University School of Economics
Social Epistemology, Vol. 18, No. 2-3, pp. 215-246, 2004
Scientific measurements are made objective through the use of reliable instruments. Instruments can have this function because they can - as material objects - be investigated independently of the specific measurements at hand. However, their materiality appears to be crucial for the assessment of their reliability. The usual strategies to investigate an instrument’s reliability depend on and assume possibilities of control, and control is usually specified in terms of materiality of the instrument and environment. The aim of this paper is to investigate the problem of reliability for non-material instruments, the instruments being applied in the social sciences. Any possible lack of reliability of the instrument hinders the measurements of ever becoming objective.
Keywords: Accuracy, Calibration, Precision, Reputation, Secrets
JEL Classification: B4
Date posted: July 18, 2009