Download this Paper Open PDF in Browser

The Problem of Time in Quantum Cosmology and Non-Chronometric Temporality

29 Pages Posted: 25 Jul 2009  

Carlos Pedro dos Santos Gonçalves

Instituto Superior de Ciências Sociais e Políticas (ISCSP)

Maria Odete Madeira

Massacritica, Lda.

Date Written: July 23, 2009


We review two lines of argument regarding the problem of time in quantum cosmology and in quantum gravity, one that invokes the path integral formalism for quantum gravity to state the absence of time between two three-geometries, and another that defends the absence of time, as a fundamental notion in physics, in terms of: (a) the configuration space argument, put forward by Barbour, Smolin and Kauffman, and (b) the Wheeler-DeWitt equation. We argue that although being correct with respect to a space-time dependent physical chronometrizable clock-time frame, both of these lines of argument fail with respect to a general sense of temporality, expressed in terms of the more elementary notions of a before and an after of a quantum computation. With respect to the first line of argument, it is shown that the early works on the subject address two kinds of temporalities, one that is the space-time geometric dependent temporality, which coincides with the usual definition of a space-time dependent physical chronometrizable clock-time frame, the other is a temporality associated to the notions of input and output of a general quantum gravity computation, that is expressed, in the theoretical discourse of quantum gravity, through the usage of the concepts of: (1) propagation of a wave functional in superspace, as addressed by Wheeler; (2) transition amplitudes of three-geometries and (3) the pathintegral formalism, used to calculate such amplitudes, as addressed by Hartle and Hawking. While the first temporality (space-time dependent temporality) disappears from the theory, the second plays a fundamental role, not only in the several aspects of the theory’s construction, but in the clock-time independence as well, as Wheeler showed. Given this notion of time, different from a chronometrizable, space-time geometry internal notion, we search for a general mathematical and logical structure that is capable of addressing it from a formal point of view. This is done through a family of mathematical structures that is more general than the mathematical category. These structures not only will allow us to address the nature of the temporality present in the transition amplitudes between two three-geometries, but they will also allow us to refute the configuration space argument and to show how a static clock-time-independent quantum state, can be put into a non-clock-time processual expression in terms of fine-grained computational histories, obtained from the relations between different observable’s bases.

Keywords: quantum cosmology, time, relational structures, relational nexus

Suggested Citation

Gonçalves, Carlos Pedro dos Santos and Madeira, Maria Odete, The Problem of Time in Quantum Cosmology and Non-Chronometric Temporality (July 23, 2009). Available at SSRN: or

Carlos Pedro Dos Santos Gonçalves (Contact Author)

Instituto Superior de Ciências Sociais e Políticas (ISCSP) ( email )

Pólo Universitário do Alto da Ajuda
Rua Almerindo Lessa - CACIFO 174
Lisbon - Lisboa, 1349-055

HOME PAGE: http://

Maria Odete Madeira

Massacritica, Lda. ( email )



Paper statistics

Abstract Views