Download this Paper Open PDF in Browser

Crime, Culpability and Moral Luck: Comment on Alexander, Ferzan and Morse

12 Pages Posted: 18 Aug 2009 Last revised: 13 Aug 2010

Alec D. Walen

Rutgers School of Law; Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey - Department of Philosophy

Date Written: March 19, 2010

Abstract

Crime and Culpability, by Larry Alexander, Kimberly Kessler Ferzan (with Stephen Morse) is a visionary work of moral and legal philosophy. Nonetheless, it is fundamentally morally misguided. In seeking to free criminal law from what the authors take to be the distorting influence of outcome luck, they arrive at a position that is overly exculpatory. It fails to hold actors liable for the harms they cause when they have taken less care they should.

I argue, first, that the authors’ attempt to strip criminal law of outcome luck is incoherent in its own terms, and that any attempt to follow through on their program would require a much more severe loss of accountability than the authors acknowledge. I then argue that outcome luck is pervasive in our moral lives, and that, given the choice of (a) not being able to hold agents accountable for much, or (b) holding them accountable for the results of their choices, including outcomes that result in part from moral luck, the right choice is (b). I wrap up with a concluding observation about the implausible moral psychology that underlies the authors’ view of culpable action.

Keywords: criminal law, culpability, moral luck, negligence, recklessness

Suggested Citation

Walen, Alec D., Crime, Culpability and Moral Luck: Comment on Alexander, Ferzan and Morse (March 19, 2010). Law and Philosophy, Vol. 29, pp. 373-384, 2010. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1448647

Alec D. Walen (Contact Author)

Rutgers School of Law ( email )

NJ
United States

Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey - Department of Philosophy ( email )

106 Somerset St
5th Floor
New Brunswick, NJ 08901
United States

Paper statistics

Downloads
209
Rank
122,264
Abstract Views
1,546