50 Pages Posted: 18 Aug 2009 Last revised: 20 Oct 2015
Date Written: December 1, 2010
States have adopted several different regimes of recognition for same-sex couples. A few states allow same-sex couples to marry; several others offer marriage-like partnerships (usually called civil unions), which provide all or nearly all of the substantive rights and responsibilities associated with marriage; still others offer marriage-lite partnerships (sometimes called reciprocal benefits arrangements), which provide a small subset of the rights and responsibilities associated with marriage; and, of course, others offer no recognition at all.
What happens when these regimes of recognition collide? For example, what happens when a couple marries in Massachusetts and then moves to a marriage-like state, like New Jersey? Will, and should, New Jersey recognize the Massachusetts marriage as a marriage under New Jersey law; or should it refuse to recognize it entirely; or should it automatically convert the relationship to New Jersey’s marriage-like alternative?
Concerning these issues, which I call the marriage/marriage-like/marriage-lite conflicts, the law is deeply unsettled. Further, until now, scholars have focused nearly exclusively on conflicts that arise between states that recognize same-sex marriage and those that offer them no recognition at all, ignoring the marriage/marriage-like/marriage-lite conflicts; and the approaches they have offered do not translate to this new context. This Article fills this lacuna and offers a new framework for resolving the marriage/marriage-like/marriage-lite conflicts. It also explores some substantial implications of this new approach.
Keywords: Same-sex marriage, interstate recognition, conflicts, choice of law
JEL Classification: K19
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Levin, Hillel Y., Resolving Interstate Conflicts Over Same-Sex Non-Marriage (December 1, 2010). Florida Law Review, Vol. 63, p. 47, 2011; UGA Legal Studies Research Paper No. 09-013. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1457082