Footnotes (227)



Bush v. Gore: Looking at Baker v. Carr in a Conservative Mirror

Robert J. Pushaw

Pepperdine University - School of Law

August 19, 2009

Constitutional Commentary, Vol. 18, 2001

In Baker v. Carr, the Warren court perceived a crisis that defied a political solution. There the Court found justiciable a claim that the Equal Protection Clause required apportionment to be based solely on population, despite the dissenters’ arguments that (1) nothing in that Clause, or any other constitutional provision, authorized this result, and (2) the majority had abandoned the principles of judicial restraint embedded in the ideas of stare decisis, justiciability, and federalism. For the past four decades, the Court has steadfastly adhered to Baker, and although some legal scholars initially criticized Baker, today the opinion meets with near-universal acclaim.

Baker laid the groundwork for the Court’s opinion in Bush v. Gore. The Court decided Bush precisely the way it decided Baker. Once again, an electoral emergency arose that struck the majority as insoluble through normal political channels. Once again, over acrimonious dissents, the Court created an unprecedented equal protection “right” and ignored concerns for both federalism and justiciability.

Notwithstanding these similarities, law professors who have canonized Baker criticize Bush. In this article, Professor Pushaw argues that intellectual consistency requires either acceptance or rejection of both Baker and Bush. He concludes that both decisions rest on similarly faulty reasoning, and thus, both decisions are wrong.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 44

Keywords: Baker v. Carr, Bush v. Gore, constititional law, political question, justiciability

JEL Classification: K40

Open PDF in Browser Download This Paper

Date posted: August 20, 2009 ; Last revised: October 8, 2010

Suggested Citation

Pushaw, Robert J., Bush v. Gore: Looking at Baker v. Carr in a Conservative Mirror (August 19, 2009). Constitutional Commentary, Vol. 18, 2001. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1458008

Contact Information

Robert J. Pushaw (Contact Author)
Pepperdine University - School of Law ( email )
24255 Pacific Coast Highway
Malibu, CA 90263
United States
(310) 506-6318 (Phone)
Feedback to SSRN

Paper statistics
Abstract Views: 538
Downloads: 53
Download Rank: 304,533
Footnotes:  227