Between Usurpation and Abdication? The Right to Health in the Courts of Brazil and South Africa

26 Pages Posted: 21 Aug 2009

See all articles by Octavio Luiz Motta Ferraz

Octavio Luiz Motta Ferraz

King's College London – The Dickson Poon School of Law

Date Written: August 20, 2009

Abstract

In this paper I argue that the dilemma between usurpation and abdication that courts inevitably face when they are called upon to adjudicate constitutionalised social and economic rights is indeed a real and intractable one. I try to substantiate my conclusion with a comparative analysis of the social rights jurisprudence of the South African and Brazilian courts (particularly in the field of the right to health) which currently stand on opposite sides of the 'justiciability spectrum'. Whereas the South African reasonableness approach is seen as too deferential and abdicative of the judiciary’s role in protecting rights, the Brazilian individually enforceable rights approach is deemed too intrusive and usurpative of the prerogative of elected representatives to define how the limited resources of the state should be allocated among unlimited social needs. I argue, also, that the emerging cooperative constitutionalism theories, which try to apply the institutional dialogue theories of judicial review to social rights adjudication, do not solve the dilemma. They are currently largely procedural, and therefore liable to the same charges of abdication levelled at the reasonableness approach of the South African Constitutional Court. But if they try to become more substantive, they will certainly attract the accusations of usurpation currently levelled at more assertive courts such as the Brazilian STF. I conclude, then, that the dilemma might be unsolvable until either a more stable consensus on what social and economic rights entail emerges or the expectation that rights necessarily imply strong judicial remedies gradually wanes.

Keywords: social and economic rights, justiciability, right to health

Suggested Citation

Ferraz, Octavio Luiz Motta, Between Usurpation and Abdication? The Right to Health in the Courts of Brazil and South Africa (August 20, 2009). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1458299 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1458299

Octavio Luiz Motta Ferraz (Contact Author)

King's College London – The Dickson Poon School of Law ( email )

Somerset House East Wing
Strand
London, WC2R 2LS
United Kingdom

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
283
rank
104,941
Abstract Views
1,848
PlumX Metrics