From New Deal Institutions to Capital Markets: Commercial Consumer Risk Scores and the Making of Subprime Mortgage Finance

52 Pages Posted: 22 Aug 2009  

Martha A. Poon

UCSD Science Studies Program

Date Written: October 27, 2008

Abstract

The investment fueled U.S. mortgage market has traditionally been sustained by New Deal institutions called government sponsored enterprises (GSEs). Known as Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, the GSEs once dominated mortgage backed securities underwriting. The recent subprime mortgage crisis has drawn attention to the fact that during the real estate boom, these agencies were temporarily overtaken by risk tolerant channels of lending, securitization, and investment, fueled by investment banks and private capital players. This research traces the movement of a specific brand of commercial consumer credit analytics into mortgage underwriting. It demonstrates that what might look like the spontaneous rise (and fall) of a ‘free’ market divested of direct government intervention has been thoroughly embedded in the concerted movement of calculative risk management technologies. The transformations began with a sequence of GSE decisions taken in the mid-1990’s to implement a consumer risk score called a FICO® into automated underwriting systems. Having been endorsed by the GSEs, this scoring tool was gradually hardwired throughout the industry to become a distributed and collective ‘market device’. As the paper will show, once modified by specific GSE interpretations the calculative properties generated by these credit bureau scores reconfigured mortgage finance into two parts: the conventional, risk-adverse, GSE conforming ‘prime’ and an infrastructurally distinct, risk-avaricious, investment grade ‘subprime’.

Keywords: consumer credit scoring, FICO® scores, Freddie Mac, market device(s), mortgage finance, risk based pricing, social studies of finance, subprime

Suggested Citation

Poon, Martha A., From New Deal Institutions to Capital Markets: Commercial Consumer Risk Scores and the Making of Subprime Mortgage Finance (October 27, 2008). Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 35, No. 5, pp. 654-674. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1458545

Martha A. Poon (Contact Author)

UCSD Science Studies Program ( email )

9500 Gilman Drive
401 SSB
La Jolla, CA 92093
United States

Paper statistics

Downloads
349
Rank
68,425
Abstract Views
3,212