Setting the Standard: A Critique of Bonnie’s Competency Standard and the Potential of Problem-Solving Theory for Self-Representation at Trial

69 Pages Posted: 10 Sep 2009 Last revised: 19 Oct 2010

See all articles by E. Lea Johnston

E. Lea Johnston

University of Florida - Levin College of Law

Date Written: September 4, 2009

Abstract

In Indiana v. Edwards, 128 S. Ct. 2379 (2008), the Supreme Court held that the Sixth Amendment permits a trial court to impose a higher competency standard for self-representation than to stand trial. The Court declined to specify the contents of a permissible representational competence standard but cited with approval the standard of adjudicative competence developed by Professor Richard Bonnie. This paper challenges the legitimacy of applying Bonnie’s standard to self-representation at trial. In particular, the normative and contextual underpinnings of Bonnie’s standard, as well as its derivation from medical treatment decisionmaking, make it insufficient for and largely inapplicable to self-representation. To illuminate abilities necessary for decisionmaking at trial, the author draws upon social problem-solving theory. Self-representation is, at base, an exercise in problem solving, where the major “problem” is the prosecution of a criminal charge. Problem-solving theory thus provides insight into fundamental components of autonomous decisionmaking at trial. Applying a normative theory of representational competence that balances concerns of autonomy, reliability, and fairness, the paper concludes by suggesting a subset of problem-solving abilities that may be critical for self-representation at trial.

Keywords: Sixth Amendment, self-representation, competency

Suggested Citation

Johnston, E. Lea, Setting the Standard: A Critique of Bonnie’s Competency Standard and the Potential of Problem-Solving Theory for Self-Representation at Trial (September 4, 2009). UC Davis Law Review, Vol. 43, 2010; University of Florida Levin College of Law Research Paper No. 2009-32. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1468365

E. Lea Johnston (Contact Author)

University of Florida - Levin College of Law ( email )

P.O. Box 117625
Gainesville, FL 32611-7625
United States

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
97
Abstract Views
734
rank
270,256
PlumX Metrics