Three Problematic Truths About the Consumer Financial Protection Agency Act of 2009
Lombard Street, Vol. 1, No. 12, September 14, 2009
27 Pages Posted: 18 Sep 2009
Date Written: September 15, 2009
The creation of a new Consumer Financial Protection Agency (“CFPA”) is a very bad idea and should be rejected. The proposal is not salvageable and cannot be improved in substance or in form. The foundational premise of the CFPA is that a failure of consumer protection, and specifically irrational consumer behavior in lending markets, was a meaningful cause of the financial crisis and that the CFPA would have or could have averted the crisis or lessened its effects. To the contrary, there is no evidence that consumer ignorance or irrationality was a substantial cause of the crisis or that the existence of a CFPA could have prevented the problems that occurred. The CFPA is likely to do more harm than good for consumers. In this article, we highlight three fundamentally problematic truths about the CFPA: (1) The CFPA is premised on a flawed understanding of the financial crisis, (2) the CFPA will have significant unintended consequences, including but not limited to reducing competition, consumer choice, and availability of credit to consumers for productive uses; and (3) the CFPA creates a powerful bureaucracy with undefined scope, risking expensive and wasteful regulatory overlap at both the federal and state levels without any evidence of its own expertise in the core areas it is designed to regulate.
Keywords: Barack Obama, behavioral economics, credit cards, Elizabeth Warren, Federal Trade Commission, Financial Regulatory Reform, Michael Barr, new paternalism, Oren Bar-Gill, plain vanilla, regulation, White Paper
JEL Classification: D18, E50, E58, G18, G24, G28, G38, K22, K23, L44, L51, R38
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
The Allocation of Governmental Regulatory Authority: Federalism and the Case of Insurance Regulation
The Occ's Preemption Rules Exceed the Agency's Authority and Present a Serious Threat to the Dual Banking System and Consumer Protection
Hydraulic Regulation: Regulating Credit Markets Upstream
State Regulation and Consumer Protection in the Insurance Industry
Consuming Debt: Structuring the Federal Response to Abuses in Consumer Credit
A Pragmatic Approach to the Phased Consolidation of Financial Regulation in the United States
The Consumer Financial Protection Agency
Keeping Both Eyes Wide Open: The Life of a Competition Authority Among Sectoral Regulators
By Pedro P. Barros, Steffen Hoernig, ...
Analyzing the Role for a Consumer Financial Protection Agency