Reforming the Regulation of Broker-Dealers and Investment Advisers
The Business Lawyer, Vol. 65, No. 2, February 2010
46 Pages Posted: 19 Oct 2009 Last revised: 1 Mar 2010
Date Written: October 19, 2009
Abstract
A key component of financial regulatory reform is harmonizing the law governing broker-dealers and investment advisers. Historically brokers charged commissions and were regulated under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Advisers charged asset-based fees and were subject to the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, which contains a special exclusion for brokers. In recent years, brokers have changed their compensation structure and many now market themselves as advisers, raising questions about whether they should be treated as such. The Obama Administration’s 2009 White Paper on regulatory reform and draft legislation call for a fiduciary duty to be imposed on brokers that provide advice. In this article, I explore the debate over regulating brokers and advisers and suggest how to resolve it. I make four key claims. First, changes in brokers’ compensation and marketing methods vitiate application of the broker-dealer exclusion and should subject brokers to the Advisers Act. Second, changes in the nature of brokerage, spurred by changes in technology, make the broker-dealer exclusion unsustainable and Congress should repeal it. I then turn to the consequences of regulating brokers as advisers. The third claim is that imposing fiduciary duties on brokers is incompatible with their historical roles as dealers and underwriters. To resolve this tension, the article suggests a compromise that enhances brokers’ duties but does not hobble their ability to perform their traditional functions. Finally, regulating brokers as advisers would overburden the SEC and the article offers alternatives to alleviate the strain.
Keywords: broker-dealer, investment adviser, securities regulation, financial regulation, fiduciary duty
JEL Classification: K22, K23, K42
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
Financial Advisors: A Case of Babysitters?
By Andreas Hackethal, Michael Haliassos, ...
-
Financial Advisors: A Case of Babysitters?
By Andreas Hackethal, Michael Haliassos, ...
-
Financial Advisors: A Case of Babysitters?
By Andreas Hackethal, Michael Haliassos, ...
-
The Market for Financial Advice: An Audit Study
By Sendhil Mullainathan, Markus Noeth, ...
-
Legal Protection in Retail Financial Markets
By Bruce I. Carlin and Simon Gervais
-
Legal Protection in Retail Financial Markets
By Bruce I. Carlin and Simon Gervais
-
Is Unbiased Financial Advice To Retail Investors Sufficient? Answers from a Large Field Study
By Utpal Bhattacharya, Andreas Hackethal, ...
-
Is Unbiased Financial Advice to Retail Investors Sufficient? Answers from a Large Field Study
By Utpal Bhattacharya, Andreas Hackethal, ...
-
Financial Advice and Individual Investor Portfolio Performance
By Marc Kramer