Equality and Identity Hierarchy

74 Pages Posted: 8 Apr 2010

See all articles by Nirej Sekhon

Nirej Sekhon

Georgia State University College of Law

Abstract

Equal protection scholars have all but abandoned the possibility that a theory of equality might explain Fourteenth Amendment jurisprudence. I develop just such a theory and use it to elucidate the Court’s reasoning in recent affirmative action and voting rights cases. In these cases, the Court has relinquished categorical colorblindness in favor of race-consciousness under limited circumstances. The Court has justified this approach as necessary for protecting the “individual,” although the Court does not precisely explain what it means when it uses that term. I argue that a theory of equality always depends upon a theory of identity and that the “individual" is an example of the latter. The Court uses “individual” to mean a being who experiences civic identity as primary to other identities, such as race, religion, occupation, and so on. “Identity hierarchy” describes this prioritization of civic identity. I rely on liberal political theory to define "identity hierarchy" and "civic identity" and argue that both concepts underwrite the Court's recent affirmative action and voting rights cases. I conclude that the Court’s equal protection jurisprudence would have greater analytic integrity if it were to promote civic identity without reliance upon identity hierarchy.

Keywords: equal protection, Fourteenth Amendment, identity, civic, race, affirmative action, voting rights, Rawls, political theory, liberalism, deontology, communitarian, republicanism

Suggested Citation

Sekhon, Nirej, Equality and Identity Hierarchy. NYU Journal of Law & Liberty, Vol. 3, p. 349, 2008, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1491856

Nirej Sekhon (Contact Author)

Georgia State University College of Law ( email )

P.O. Box 4037
Atlanta, GA 30302-4037
United States
404-413-9166 (Phone)

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
77
Abstract Views
647
rank
339,980
PlumX Metrics