61 Pages Posted: 27 Oct 2009 Last revised: 19 Jun 2015
Date Written: December 21, 2011
Using a hand-collected data set of private firm acquisitions and IPOs, this paper develops the first empirical analysis in the literature of the "IPO valuation premium puzzle," which refers to a situation where many private firms choose to be acquired rather than to go public at higher valuations. We also test several new hypotheses regarding a private firm's choice between IPOs and acquisitions. Our analysis of private firm valuations in IPOs and acquisitions indicates that IPO valuation premia disappear for larger VC backed firms after controlling for various observable factors affecting a firm's propensity to choose IPOs over acquisitions. Further, after controlling for the long-run component of the expected payoff to firm insiders from an IPO exit, we find that the IPO valuation premium vanishes even for larger non-VC backed firms and shrinks substantially for smaller firms as well. Our Heckman-style treatment effects regression analysis demonstrates that the above results are robust to controlling for the selection of exit mechanism by firm insiders based on unobservables. Our findings on private firms' choice between IPOs and acquisitions can be summarized as follows. First, firms operating in industries characterized by the absence of a dominant market player (and therefore more viable against product market competition) are more likely to go public rather than to be acquired. Second, more capital intensive firms, those operating in industries characterized by greater private benefits of control, and those which are harder to value by IPO market investors are more likely to go public rather than to be acquired. Third, the likelihood of an IPO over an acquisition is greater for venture backed firms and those characterized by higher pre-exit sales growth.
Keywords: IPOs, Acquisitions, Valuation premium, Private firms, Exit mechanisms, Going public
JEL Classification: G24, G32, G34
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Bayar, Onur and Chemmanur, Thomas J., What Drives the Valuation Premium in IPOs versus Acquisitions? An Empirical Analysis (December 21, 2011). Journal of Corporate Finance, June 2012, 18 (3), 451-475. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1494058 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1494058