Footnotes (12)



Book Review: Defending Humanity

Alexander K. A. Greenawalt

Pace University School of Law

August 19, 2009

New Criminal Law Review, Forthcoming

Few issues are both more central to and more elusive for the project of international law than identifying the conditions under which the use of armed force is justified. In Defending Humanity (Oxford, 2008), Fletcher & Ohlin join the debate on this issue with the provocative claim that international law has been impoverished by its neglect of the more developed doctrines of self-defense existing in domestic criminal law. The authors argue for and elaborate upon a six-part model of “legitimate defense” that justifies the defensive use of force against attacks that are (1) overt, (2) unlawful, and (3) imminent; provided the defense is (4) necessary, (5) proportional, and (6) knowing or intentional.

The authors’ approach is especially effective when it reveals how international law scholarship has either ignored the lessons of criminal law principles or misread them to defend an overly narrow doctrine of self-defense. Too often, however, the authors’ argument is weakened by confusion surrounding how best to analogize the “self” of domestic self-defense for the international context. The authors’ approach to the problem of humanitarian intervention is especially troublesome: they argue that the international community may intervene when a state attacks its own population, but only if the attacked people are a “nation.” The authors are too quick to reject a more inclusive theory of humanitarian intervention rooted in respect for human rights. This path too, is fraught with difficulty, but it better aspires to the promise of the book’s title: that of defending humanity, and not contested social constructs.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 3

Open PDF in Browser Download This Paper

Date posted: November 6, 2009 ; Last revised: January 25, 2010

Suggested Citation

Greenawalt, Alexander K. A., Book Review: Defending Humanity (August 19, 2009). New Criminal Law Review, Forthcoming. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1500644

Contact Information

Alexander K. A. Greenawalt (Contact Author)
Pace University School of Law ( email )
78 North Broadway
White Plains, NY 10603
United States
914-422-4092 (Phone)
914-422-4168 (Fax)
HOME PAGE: http://www.law.pace.edu/facbios/greenawalt.html
Feedback to SSRN

Paper statistics
Abstract Views: 642
Downloads: 57
Download Rank: 290,676
Footnotes:  12