The European Union’s Proposed Carbon Equalization System: Can It be WTO Compatible?

88 Pages Posted: 14 Apr 2010

See all articles by Biswajit Dhar

Biswajit Dhar

Independent

Kasturi Das

India Habitat Centre - Research and Information System for Developing countries (RIS)

Date Written: November 25, 2009

Abstract

Among the issues that have fuelled the debates on the climate-trade interface in the run-up to Copenhagen, perhaps the most contested one is the proposed use by developed countries of border measures on imports from countries (read ‘major-emitting’ developing countries) not implementing comparable GHG (green house gas) emissions reduction policies on the grounds of addressing the risk of what has been coined as ‘carbon leakage’. It is argued that if stringent domestic climate action causes their firms to relocate to other countries with less stringent or no carbon constraint, or to lose market share to firms from countries having low emission standards, then the emission reduction achieved in countries imposing stringent measures will be offset to a great extent by an increase in emissions elsewhere. In keeping with the above arguments, law makers in both the US and the EU have proposed introduction of carbon tariffs in order to obviate the disadvantages that their domestic products may face vis-à-vis imports as a result of emission reduction measures being adopted by them. A highly controversial issue pertaining to such carbon tariffs is whether they could be compatible with the WTO (World Trade Organization) commitments of the countries introducing such measures. This concern has found reflection not only in the post-2012 climate-energy package of the EU itself, but also in the debates on the domestic climate legislations in the EU and US. Against this backdrop, this paper makes an attempt to analyze the WTO compatibility or otherwise of the border measure proposed by the EU in its post-2012 climate-energy package.

Keywords: border tax adjustment, carbon equalization system, climate change, carbon tariff, EU, US, WTO jurisprudence, compatibility

Suggested Citation

Dhar, Biswajit and Das, Kasturi, The European Union’s Proposed Carbon Equalization System: Can It be WTO Compatible? (November 25, 2009). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1513231 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1513231

Biswajit Dhar

Independent ( email )

Kasturi Das (Contact Author)

India Habitat Centre - Research and Information System for Developing countries (RIS) ( email )

Core 4B, 4th Floor, Lodhi Road
India Habitat Centre
New Delhi, Delhi 110003
India

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
222
Abstract Views
1,180
Rank
248,388
PlumX Metrics