Why Violence? Because the Irrationalities Induced by Choice Frames Make Perfect Evolutionary Sense
25 Pages Posted: 15 Dec 2009
Date Written: December 15, 2009
Abstract
This paper argues that strength deters violence and weakness elicits it because selection favors moral relativism and choices framed as gains between equals but moral clarity and choices framed as losses as inequalities grow. Deterrents consist of evolutionarily significant consequences for violent acts, but their credibility (and effects) should vary with the likelihood that people frame choices as gains or losses. Findings consistent with these claims come from (1) tests for cycle-of-violence effects on structured interview data for 344 post-transition men and women in Barbados, (2) tests for violence exposure effects on structured interview data for 165 men and women from Colombia, Denmark, Israel, South Africa, and the United States, and (3) a comprehensive test for framing effects with a pooled cross-sectional time-series on violent crime rates and the likelihood of evolutionarily significant consequences for violence perpetrators in the United States. Significant violence rate reductions may come from interventions that target choice frames either directly (for adults) or indirectly, by reducing violence toward children. The greatest violence rate reductions may require the creation of intervention cultures.
Keywords: Violence, IPV, Terrorism, Rational Choice Theory, Choice Frames
JEL Classification: C70,D70,D74,D80
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
By Erdal Tekin and Janet Currie
-
By Janet Currie and Erdal Tekin
-
Suicidal Behavior and the Labor Market Productivity of Young Adults
By Erdal Tekin and Sara Markowitz
-
Suicidal Behavior and the Labor Market Productivity of Young Adults
By Erdal Tekin and Sara Markowitz
-
Neighborhood Violence and Urban Youth
By Anna Aizer
-
The Effect of Childhood Conduct Disorder on Human Capital
By Pierre Koning, H. Dinand Webbink, ...
-
By Rodrigo R. Soares and Igor Viveiros