Evidence and Feminism
Feminist Jurisprudence, Women and The Law: Critical Essays and Articles, Betty W. Taylor, Sharon Rush, Robert John, eds., 1999
41 Pages Posted: 12 Feb 2010 Last revised: 10 Jul 2013
Date Written: 1999
This essay reviews some of the existing literature on women and evidence and suggests some directions for future research. Part I outlines a definition of feminism and an approach to feminist analysis. Part II briefly reviews some current attempts to probe the gendered nature of evidence and to apply feminist principles. Part III considers areas such as rape shield, character evidence, and privilege where feminist goals and insights offer concrete suggestions to shape evidence law. Part IV discusses expert testimony in rape trauma and battered woman syndromes where feminism proposes no changes in evidence law per se, but instead reinvigorates existing doctrine to educate the factfinder about women’s lives. Part V analyzes the notion of courtroom “truth” and how that truth influences the reception of women in the courtroom. Part VI examines hearsay. Part VII discusses the relationship between feminist method and the adversary system. Finally Part VIII considers the effect of a feminist critique on evidence teaching and scholarship.
Keywords: evidence, feminism
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation