Footnotes (159)



Unbundling Homeownership: Regional Reforms From the Inside Out

Nicole Stelle Garnett

Notre Dame Law School


Yale Law Journal, Vol. 119, p. 1904, 2010
Notre Dame Legal Studies Paper No. 10-05

Two vexing puzzles plague American land use regulators. The first puzzle is how to protect property owners from harmful spillovers without unduly stifling land use diversity. The dominant forms of land use regulation in the United States - zoning and private covenants - rely on ex ante prohibitions. Yet, since local governments and private developers rarely can calibrate the level of regulation to residents’ true preferences, the costs imposed by these regulations tend to exceed the benefits of actual harm prevention. The result is the over-protection of property owners and, and, many would argue, a monotonous, sterile, inefficient, and inconvenient suburban landscape. The second puzzle is how to address the intrametropolitan inequalities resulting from the fragmented distribution of regulatory authority without undercutting the beneficial effects of inter-jurisdictional competition. While this puzzle extends beyond property law, land use regulations are particularly problematic because they empower local jurisdictions to exclude unwanted residents. The difficulty is, however, that most proposed strategies to address this second puzzle threaten to undermine the efficiency gains that are produced when, as Charles Tiebout influentially predicted, local governments compete with one another for residents. By treating these two land use puzzles as property-entitlement problems, rather than regulatory-design problems, The Unbounded Home breaks free from standard land-use and local-government debates and offers novel solutions to address seemingly intractable difficulties. This review focuses on the two of Fennell’s proposals that, in my view, hold the most promise: First, the use of “entitlements subject to self-made options” or “ESSMOs”, to address local land use spillovers; and second, the reconfiguration of home-ownership to minimize owners’ incentives to demand that exclusionary land use policies.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 44

Keywords: land use, Tiebout, regional government, zoning, covenants, urban development

Open PDF in Browser Download This Paper

Date posted: March 5, 2010 ; Last revised: November 16, 2011

Suggested Citation

Garnett, Nicole Stelle, Unbundling Homeownership: Regional Reforms From the Inside Out (2010). Yale Law Journal, Vol. 119, p. 1904, 2010; Notre Dame Legal Studies Paper No. 10-05. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1564963

Contact Information

Nicole Stelle Garnett (Contact Author)
Notre Dame Law School ( email )
P.O. Box 780
Notre Dame, IN 46556
United States
574-631-3091 (Phone)
HOME PAGE: http://www.law.nd.edu/faculty/facultypages/garnettn.html

Feedback to SSRN

Paper statistics
Abstract Views: 559
Downloads: 74
Download Rank: 255,764
Footnotes:  159