The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and Legal Realism as a Jurisprudence of Law Reform

79 Pages Posted: 5 Apr 2010

Date Written: March 1, 2010

Abstract

Since the 1930s, legal realism has weathered claims that its adherents had no use for legal rules and lacked a positive program of law reform. This article uses the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, the major procedural reform of the twentieth century, to illuminate more accurately the treatment of rules in realism as well as its constructive potential. It draws upon the published and unpublished writings of Charles Clark, the primary author of the Federal Rules and a leading realist, to describe a realist procedural jurisprudence and to explain why the Federal Rules neatly illustrate this jurisprudence in practice. Part I draws upon classical pragmatism, realism’s philosophical antecedent, to depict more accurately the place of rules and reform in realism. Two principles – an emphasis on the functional competence of rules to achieve particular ends, and faith in methods of inquiry over theories of ultimate ends – marked realists’ approach to both. Part II shows why procedural reform would attract a realist like Clark. Prior procedural regimes suffered from the same formalism that beset the substantive common law in the late nineteenth century. Clark developed his procedural jurisprudence in reaction to this formalism, emphasizing functional competence and good methods of inquiry as key principles. Part III then explains how these principles and Clark’s distaste for procedural formalism shaped the Federal Rules in important ways. The article concludes with a discussion of the promises and shortcomings of realism as a jurisprudence of law reform.

Keywords: legal realism, pleading, Charles Clark, jurisprudence

Suggested Citation

Marcus, David, The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and Legal Realism as a Jurisprudence of Law Reform (March 1, 2010). Georgia Law Review, Vol. 44, p. 433, 2010, Arizona Legal Studies Discussion Paper No 10-11, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1583102

David Marcus (Contact Author)

UCLA School of Law

385 Charles E. Young Dr. East
Los Angeles, CA 90095
United States
3107945192 (Phone)

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
382
Abstract Views
2,036
rank
90,433
PlumX Metrics