Determining Gender Equity in Fiscal Federalism: Analytical Issues and Empirical Evidence from India
Levy Economics Institute Working Papers Series No. 590
28 Pages Posted: 7 Apr 2010
Date Written: March 2010
Despite the policy realm’s growing recognition of fiscal devolution in gender development, there have been relatively few attempts to translate gender commitments into fiscal commitments. This paper aims to engage in this significant debate, focusing on the plausibility of incorporating gender into financial devolution, with the Thirteenth Finance Commission of India as backdrop. Given the disturbing demographics - the monotonous decline in the juvenile sex ratio, especially in some of the prosperous states of India - there can be no valid objection to using Finance Commission transfers for this purpose. A simple method for accomplishing this could be to introduce some weight in favor of the female population of the states in the Commission’s fiscal devolution formula. The message would be even stronger and more appropriate if the population of girl children only - that is, the number of girls in the 0-6 age cohort - is adopted as the basis for determining the states’ relative shares of the amount to be disbursed by applying the allotted weight. A special dispensation for girls would also be justifiable in a scheme of need-based equalization transfers. While social mores cannot be changed by fiscal fiats, particularly when prejudices run deep, a proactive approach by a high constitutional body like the Finance Commission is called for, especially when the prejudices are blatantly oppressive. Indeed, such action is imperative. The intergovernmental transfer system can and should play a role in upholding the right to life for India’s girl children. That being said, it needs to be mentioned that it is not plausible to incorporate more gender variables in the Finance Commission’s already complex transfer formula. In other words, inclusion of a “gender inequality index” in the formula may not result in the intended results, as the variables included in the index may cancel one another out. Accepting the fact that incorporating gender criteria in fiscal devolution could only be the second-best principle for engendering fiscal policy, the paper argues that newfound policy space for the feminization of local governance, coupled with an engendered fiscal devolution to the third tier, can lead to public expenditure decisions that correspond more closely to the revealed preferences (“voice”) of women. With the 73rd and 74th constitutional amendments, this policy space is favorable at the local level for conducting gender responsive budgeting.
Keywords: Fiscal Decentralization, Federalism, Fiscal Transfers, Gender
JEL Classification: H77, J16
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
The Costs of Missing the Millennium Development Goal on Gender Equity
By Dina Abu-ghaida and Stephan Klasen
Gender Equality, Poverty and Economic Growth
By Nistha Sinha, Dhushyanth Raju, ...
Gender Discrimination and Growth: Theory and Evidence from India
Gender and its Relevance to Macroeconomic Policy: A Survey
Are There Gender-Separate Human Capital Effects on Growth? A Review of the Recent Empirical Literature
The Effects of Fiscal Policies on the Economic Development of Women in the Middle East and North Africa
By N. Laframboise and Tea Trumbic
Gender-Responsive Government Budgeting