The Structural Safeguards of Federal Jurisdiction

72 Pages Posted: 8 Apr 2010 Last revised: 7 Jun 2014

Tara Leigh Grove

William & Mary Law School

Date Written: February 2011

Abstract

Scholars have long debated Congress’s power to curb federal jurisdiction and have consistently assumed that the constitutional limits on Congress’s authority (if any) must be judicially enforceable and found in the text and structure of Article III. In this Article, I challenge that fundamental assumption. I argue that the primary constitutional protection for the federal judiciary lies instead in the bicameralism and presentment requirements of Article I. These Article I lawmaking procedures give competing political factions (even political minorities) considerable power to “veto” legislation. Drawing on recent social science and legal scholarship, I argue that political factions are particularly likely to use their structural veto to block jurisdiction-stripping legislation favored by their opponents. Notably, this structural argument is supported by the history of congressional control over federal jurisdiction. When the federal courts have issued controversial opinions that trigger wide public condemnation, supporters of the judiciary - even when they were only a political minority in Congress - repeatedly used their structural veto to block jurisdiction-stripping proposals. This structural approach also provides one answer to a puzzle that has particularly troubled scholars: whether there are any constitutional limits on Congress’s authority to make “exceptions” to the Supreme Court’s appellate jurisdiction. The structural safeguards of Article I have proven especially effective at preventing encroachments on the Supreme Court’s Article III appellate review power.

Suggested Citation

Grove, Tara Leigh, The Structural Safeguards of Federal Jurisdiction (February 2011). Harvard Law Review, Vol. 124, Forthcoming; FSU College of Law, Public Law Research Paper No. 434; FSU College of Law, Law, Business & Economics Paper No. 10-6. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1585973

Tara Leigh Grove (Contact Author)

William & Mary Law School ( email )

South Henry Street
P.O. Box 8795
Williamsburg, VA 23187-8795
United States

Paper statistics

Downloads
288
Rank
84,366
Abstract Views
1,567