Medical Negligence and Criminal Law: An Indian Perspective

7 Pages Posted: 16 Apr 2010

See all articles by Prashant R. Dahat

Prashant R. Dahat

National Law Institute University, Bhopal

Puneet Satbir Yadav

National Law Institute University (NLIU)

Date Written: April 16, 2010

Abstract

The word “negligence” is always damaging to the reputation of doctors, related to some damage to the patient and a challenge before the judges. In recent years, sudden spurt in the cases of “Criminal negligence” and decision of the Supreme Court raises a fresh debate.

This paper deals with current scenario of “Criminal Negligence”, applicability of Section 304 & 304-A IPC in cases of death of patient during treatment, remedial measures available to a doctor facing the charge of ‘Criminal Negligence’ and a brief discussion of important cases related to the issue, including recent case.

Negligence is a term of art, but has distinct meanings in different jurisdictions. In ‘Tort’, damage is an essential ingredient but that element is not necessary in the law of master and servant. In criminal law, there are series of offences based on negligence in which loss or injury is not material; it is enough if the act is likely to cause injury or endanger life. Operation of patient without consent is an example of negligence (Statutory Damage) even without actual apparent damage. Dictionary meaning of term ‘Negligence’ is ‘Lack of Proper Care’. As defined by Baron Alderson negligence means: “Omission to do something which a reasonable man guided by those consideration which regulate conduct of human affairs would do, or doing something which a reasonable man would not do”. Same definition is quoted in many decisions of the court. ‘Criminal Negligence’ is an offence against the State while ‘Civil Negligence’ is an offence against the individual act, which leads to injury i.e. physical injury, hurt- Section 319, grievous hurt- Section 320 Indian Penal Code (IPC). Loss of property (financial loss) due to some negligent act is always a civil negligence. The decision of the Supreme Court delivered on last years raises a fresh debate on the issue of ‘Criminal Negligence by the Doctors’. In this case the Supreme Court relied on various decisions of the House of Lords.

Keywords: Indian criminal laws on medical negligence, An Indian Perspective on Medical Negligence

Suggested Citation

Dahat, Prashant Ramdas and Yadav, Puneet Satbir, Medical Negligence and Criminal Law: An Indian Perspective (April 16, 2010). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1591159 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1591159

Prashant Ramdas Dahat

National Law Institute University, Bhopal ( email )

108-A, Boy's Hostel,
Kerwa Dam Road,
Bhopal - 462044. ( M.P.), Madhya Pradesh 462044
India
09770338751 (Phone)

Puneet Satbir Yadav (Contact Author)

National Law Institute University (NLIU) ( email )

Kerwa Dam Road
Kerwa Dam Road,
Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh 462044
India

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
1,187
Abstract Views
5,050
rank
21,355
PlumX Metrics