Understanding the Impact of Economic Shocks on Labor Market Outcomes in Developing Countries: An Application to Indonesia and Mexico

29 Pages Posted: 20 Apr 2016

Date Written: April 1, 2010


In this paper the authors use a search and matching model of multi-sector labor markets, to understand the channels through which economic shocks affect labor market outcomes in developing countries. In the model workers can be employed in agriculture, formal or informal urban jobs, or unemployed. Economic shocks are manifested as either increased turbulence in the formal/informal sectors or a decrease in overall sectoral productivity. By calibrating the model to Indonesia and Mexico, the authors are able to understand how the 1998 Indonesian crisis and the 2001 Mexican recession translated into labor market outcomes. They then venture to simulate how the current financial crisis might affect the allocation of labor and earnings across sectors, in these countries. The results suggest that in both countries past crises have increased the degree of turbulence of the formal sector, increasing job destruction. However, while in Indonesia the crisis affected the overall formal sector productivity, this was not the case in Mexico. This explains the larger blow to formal wages -- relative to the size of the shock- witnessed by Indonesian workers. The response of the informal sector was also different: In both countries the informal sector was able to act as a buffer, as relative earnings increased. However, while in Mexico it became much harder to find informal sector opportunities and easier to keep the job once found; in Indonesia turbulence in the informal sector increased substantially increasing the job destruction rate of informal jobs and limiting the cushioning role that the informal sector might have played. The agricultural sector was spared from the shock in both countries. In Indonesia, it actually benefited from an unusual exogenous increase in the price of rise. The simulations show that if either the informal or agricultural sectors are spared from the shocks, large reallocations of labor might occur, and the overall effect of the shock is smaller. Instead, if these sectors can?t buffer the shock, the reallocation of labor is much smaller, but earnings in the formal sector drop substantially. The authors also explore the impact of alternative policies. They find that in relatively flexible markets where informality can be seen more as a choice rather than as queuing, unemployment benefits and informal employment subsidies may have paradoxical effects, by discouraging formal search. Instead, policies targeted at creating informal employment and boosting formal TFP growth have the desired effects.

Keywords: Labor Markets, Labor Policies, Markets and Market Access, Banks & Banking Reform, Economic Theory & Research

Suggested Citation

Gutierrez, Catalina and Paci, Pierella and Park, Beom S., Understanding the Impact of Economic Shocks on Labor Market Outcomes in Developing Countries: An Application to Indonesia and Mexico (April 1, 2010). World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 5283, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1597056

Catalina Gutierrez (Contact Author)

World Bank ( email )

Washington, DC 20433
United States

Pierella Paci

World Bank ( email )

Washington, DC 20433
United States

Beom S. Park

Georgetown University ( email )

Washington, DC 20057
United States
202-687-5601 (Phone)

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
PlumX Metrics