The Impact of ‘Merit Selection’ on the Characteristics of Rhode Island Judges

18 Pages Posted: 3 May 2010 Last revised: 24 Sep 2015

See all articles by Michael J. Yelnosky

Michael J. Yelnosky

Roger Williams University School of Law

Date Written: April 30, 2010

Abstract

As part of a symposium examining the impact of a merit selection system adopted for state court judges in Rhode Island in 1993, I attempted to identify any statistically significant differences in the characteristics of “merit selection” judges and their predecessors. I found that merit selection appears to have had little if any impact on most of the background characteristics I studied, which is consistent with most of the literature on the subject. However, I found that merit selection judges are less likely than their predecessors to have graduated from Providence College, and far fewer graduated from Boston University Law School, suggesting more diversity in educational background. On the other hand, an increasing number of judges chosen under merit selection attended the same law school – Suffolk – and even under merit selection over half of the judges selected attended either BU or Suffolk. This “preference” for graduates from Suffolk under merit selection may be part of a general trend suggested by the data away from preferring judicial candidates who have attended more prestigious law schools.

By far, the most robust finding of the possible impact of merit selection is the decline in the number of applicants selected who had worked in state government. Only 1 in 5 of the merit selection judges worked in the General Assembly as legislators or legislative counsel to House or Senate leadership. Reducing the influence of the General Assembly on the judiciary was a primary motivation for the switch to merit selection, and at least by this measure, the early returns suggest it may be helping to accomplish that goal.

Suggested Citation

Yelnosky, Michael J., The Impact of ‘Merit Selection’ on the Characteristics of Rhode Island Judges (April 30, 2010). Roger Williams University Law Review, Vol. 15, p. 649, 2010, Roger Williams Univ. Legal Studies Paper No. 90, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1598521

Michael J. Yelnosky (Contact Author)

Roger Williams University School of Law ( email )

10 Metacom Avenue
Bristol, RI 02809
United States
401 254-4607 (Phone)

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
41
Abstract Views
578
PlumX Metrics