Is it Immoral to Punish the Heedless and Clueless?

22 Pages Posted: 16 May 2010 Last revised: 19 Mar 2017

See all articles by Susan A. Bandes

Susan A. Bandes

DePaul University - College of Law

Date Written: May 14, 2010

Abstract

Criminal prosecutions for negligent conduct have long been controversial. As a policy matter, there are strong arguments both for and against criminalizing negligence. One obvious drawback of doctrines that insulate negligent conduct from criminal liability is that they reward heedless and clueless behavior. The actor who somehow fails to pay attention to well-know risks (driving while drunk or texting, leaving an infant in the bath unattended) is off the hook, while the actor who has the risks in mind and engages in the risky behavior anyway may be liable. But for some theorists, these policy considerations should never be reached because it is immoral to punish negligent behavior. These theorists argue that negligent actors are simply incapable of acting differently. If a parent forgets that his infant is in the bath and that infants can drown when unsupervised, his behavior is beyond his own control, and beyond the influence of the legal system. This paper critiques the assumption that the negligent actor is impervious to influence or correction, arguing that it is increasingly at odds with evolving knowledge in the fields of cognitive psychology and cognitive neuroscience. The boundary between conscious and unconscious behavior is permeable and dynamic. Unconscious behavior can be shaped and trained, and legal institutions are in a unique position to shape norms that guide unconscious or subconscious behavior.

Suggested Citation

Bandes, Susan A., Is it Immoral to Punish the Heedless and Clueless? (May 14, 2010). Law and Philosophy, Vol. 29, 2010. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1608112 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1608112

Susan A. Bandes (Contact Author)

DePaul University - College of Law ( email )

25 E. Jackson Blvd.
Chicago, IL Cook County 60604-2287
United States
(312) 362-8701 (Phone)

HOME PAGE: http://www.susanbandes.com/

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
69
rank
325,676
Abstract Views
774
PlumX Metrics