American Journal of International Law, July 2010
59 Pages Posted: 11 Aug 2010 Last revised: 22 Sep 2010
Date Written: April 30, 2010
This article describes the Supreme Court’s jurisprudence on the geographic reach of federal statutes. It argues that the Court’s decisions are a parade of inconsistencies that fail to give clear guidance to lower courts, the executive branch, and Congress. The result is that no one can know with any certainty whether a statute of general application will be construed to extend to places outside U.S. boundaries but under U.S. control, such as Guantanamo Bay, or to foreign activities with domestic effects, or to foreign ships within U.S. territory.
The article proposes that the Court return its jurisprudence to coherence by adopting a new canon: a presumption against extrajurisdictionality. Under the proposal, the Court would look for guidance to the body of international law that allocates legislative jurisdiction among countries. If that law provides the United States with sole or primary legislative jurisdiction over a situation, the Court would have a green light to construe the statute without any presumption against its application. If the United States has no basis for jurisdiction, the light would be red. There would be a strict presumption against application of the statute, which could be overcome only by a clear statement in the law itself. Finally, situations in neither of these categories would fall under a yellow light: if the United States has some basis for jurisdiction, but not the sole or primary basis, then the Court would employ a soft presumption against application of the statute, which could be overcome by any indication of legislative intent to do so.
The final version of this article will be published in the July 2010 issue of the American Journal of International Law. A much earlier draft was published on SSRN in February 2009, under the name “Legislative Jurisdiction, Judicial Canons, and International Law.”
Keywords: judicial canons, legislative jurisdiction, jurisdiction to prescribe, presumption against extraterritoriality
JEL Classification: K33
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Knox, John H., A Presumption Against Extrajurisdictionality (April 30, 2010). American Journal of International Law, July 2010; Wake Forest Univ. Legal Studies Paper No. 1657126. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1657126
By Lisa Ikemoto