Applicant Reactions in Selection: Comprehensive Meta-Analysis into Reaction Generalization Versus Situational Specificity
14 Pages Posted: 24 Aug 2010
Abstract
This paper reports a comprehensive quantitative summary into applicant reactions to popular methods of employee selection. A detailed search of published and unpublished studies resulted in a final sample (k) of 38 independent samples covering 10 popular candidate assessment methods. Applicant reactions primary studies included samples from 17 countries internationally. Counter to previous suggestions for the situational specificity of applicant reactions, findings showed considerable similarity supporting the reaction generalizability hypothesis. Reaction favorability was structurally similar across countries and revealed a three-tier clustering of overall favorability perceptions –most preferred (work samples, interviews), favorably evaluated (resumes, cognitive tests, references, biodata, personality inventories), and least preferred (honesty tests, personal contacts, graphology). Some differences in applicant reactions to dimension-specific perceptions were found, however. Further analyses revealed strong positive correlations between favorability ratings and their validity and international usage. Implications for future research and ramifications for practice are considered in conclusion.
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you want regular updates from SSRN on Twitter?
Recommended Papers
-
Effects of Explanations on Applicant Reactions: A Meta-Analytic Review
By Donald M. Truxillo, Todd Bodner, ...
-
Applicant Perspectives in Selection: Going Beyond Preference Reactions
By Ute R. Hülsheger and Neil Anderson
-
Perceived Job Discrimination: Toward a Model of Applicant Propensity to Case Initiation in Selection
-
Exploring the Construct of Perceived Job Discrimination in Selection
By Fiona Patterson and Lara D. Zibarras
-
By Frederik Anseel and Filip Lievens
-
‘Be Cool!’: Emotional Costs of Hiding Feelings in a Job Interview
-
Rejected But Still There: Shifting the Focus in Applicant Reactions to the Promotional Context
By Deborah Ford, Donald M. Truxillo, ...
-
A Closer Look at the Mechanisms of Perceived Job Discrimination: ‘How I Think You Think About Us’
-
Creating Alternate In-Basket Forms Through Cloning: Some Preliminary Results
By Filip Lievens and Frederik Anseel