Efficiency Considerations in Merger Enforcement
118 Pages Posted: 9 Oct 2010
Date Written: December 1, 1983
Abstract
This is one of the first articles to demonstrate that the primary goal of antitrust is neither exclusively to enhance economic efficiency, nor to address any social or political factor. Rather, the overriding intent behind the merger laws was to prevent prices to purchasers from rising due to mergers (a wealth transfer concern). This is the first article to show how to analyze mergers with this goal in mind. Doing so challenges the fundamental underpinnings of Williamsonian merger analysis (which assumes mergers should be evaluated only in terms of net efficiency effects).
In this and three related articles we re-do the Williamsonian tradeoff, using price to consumers, instead of net efficiencies, as our focus. We show how a price focus would require substantially more efficiencies to justify an otherwise anticompetitive merger. We demonstrate this by calculating how large the necessary efficiency gains would have to be to prevent price increases under different market conditions. We also show that under efficiency analysis even a tiny cost savings would justify almost any merger, so a purely efficiency-based approach effectively would negate the anti-merger laws! Finally, we demonstrate that price analysis is much more predictable and easier to administer than efficiency analysis.
Keywords: Antitrust, Mergers, Goals of Antitrust, Efficiency, Williamson, Price Effects, Wealth Transfers, Clayton Act, Efficiency Defense
JEL Classification: K19, K21, K29, K39, L40, L41, L49
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
Unilateral Competitive Effects of Horizontal Mergers
By Gregory J. Werden and Luke M. Froeb
-
Post-Merger Product Repositioning
By Amit Kumar Gandhi, Luke M. Froeb, ...
-
Pass-Through Rates and the Price Effects of Mergers
By Luke M. Froeb, Steven Tschantz, ...
-
Mergers when Firms Compete by Choosing both Price and Promotion
By Luke M. Froeb, Steven Tenn, ...
-
Calibrated Economic Models Add Focus, Accuracy, and Persuasiveness to Merger Analysis
By Gregory J. Werden and Luke M. Froeb
-
Merger Simulation with Brand-Level Margin: Extending Pcaids with Nests
-
Vertical Restraints and the Effects of Upstream Horizontal Mergers
By Luke M. Froeb, Steven Tschantz, ...
-
Quantifying the Scope for Efficiency Defense in Merger Control: The Werden-Froeb-Index