Should Public Retirement Plans Be Fully Funded?
41 Pages Posted: 4 Oct 2010 Last revised: 4 May 2023
Date Written: September 2010
Abstract
Most state and local retirement plans strive for full funding, at least by actuarial standards. Funding measured at market values fluctuates and often falls short. A common argument for full funding is that pensions are a form of deferred compensation that does not justify a debt. The paper examines public finance, political economy, and financial market issues that bear on optimal funding, broadly and in a series of models.In a model where most taxpayers hold debt and face intermediation costs, returns on pension assets are less than taxpayers' cost of borrowing. Pension funding is costly and hence zero funding is optimal. The model also implies that unfunded pension promises are properly discounted at a rate strictly greater than the government's borrowing rate. If pension funds serve as collateral, funding can be warranted despite the cost. This is shown in a model with legal ambiguity and default risk. Except in special cases, the optimal funding ratio is less than full funding.
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Intergenerational Risk Sharing within Funded Pension Schemes
By Jiajia Cui, Frank De Jong, ...
-
Valuation of Intergenerational Transfers in Funded Collective Pension Schemes
-
Pension Deals and Value-Based ALM
By Niels Kortleve and Eduard H.m. Ponds
-
Public Investment Funds and Value-Based Generational Accounting
By Roy P. M. M. Hoevenaars, Roderick Molenaar, ...
-
Public Investment Funds and Value-Based Generational Accounting
By Eduard H.m. Ponds, Roy P. M. M. Hoevenaars, ...
-
The Recent Evolution of Pension Funds in the Netherlands: The Trend to Hybrid DB-DC Plans and Beyond
By Eduard H.m. Ponds and Bart Van Riel
-
Pension Funds in the Netherlands
By Angelien A. G. Z. Kemna, Eduard H.m. Ponds, ...
-
Valuation of Contingent Pension Liabilities and Guarantees under Sponsor Vulnerability
-
An Options Pricing Method for Calculating the Market Price of Public Sector Pension Liabilities