Bank Lending to the Production Sector: Credit Crunch or Extra - Credit?
Temi di Economia e Finanza Working Paper No. 1
35 Pages Posted: 9 Oct 2010
Date Written: November 30, 2009
Abstract
This paper provides empirical evidence to support the theory that, in Italy, over the course of the past two years, even though a considerable slowdown in bank lending has been recorded, there has not been a credit crunch. After a first section dedicated to a descriptive analysis of the data, the paper presents an econometric estimation of the production sector’s demand for bank loans. An Error Correction Model (ECM) is used – estimated for the pre-crisis period (1998.Q2 – 2007.Q2) and applied both with the one and two step procedure – which considers lending as a function of the added value of the private sector, of the gross operating margin to nominal added value ratio (a proxy for self-financing) and of the real interest rate applied to loans. To test the robustness of the results obtained in the first specification of the model, we remove the assumption of weak exogeneity of the independent variables of the single equation model and construct a multivariate multi-equation model (VECM). All of the different approaches and methods adopted provided similar results: as expected, the demand for credit increases as real added value increases and decreases as the cost of lending and self-financing increase. The dynamic out-of-sample forecast of the model, relating to the two-year period of economic and financial crisis (2007.Q3 – 2009.Q2), shows that the actual loan stock remained well above the “theoretical” level forecasted on the basis of the functional relationships estimated before the crisis. This delta (which can be defined as “extra-credit”) is interpreted as the outcome of a rightward shift of the credit supply curve, rather than a leftward shift as would have happened in a credit crunch scenario.
Keywords: credit crunch, Italian banks, bank lending, production sector, loan demand, error correction model, cointegration
JEL Classification: C32, C51, E44
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
By Luca Casolaro, Ginette Eramo, ...
-
By Luca Casolaro and Leonardo Gambacorta
-
Modeling Bank Lending in the Euro Area: A Non-Linear Approach
-
Macroeconomic Determinants of Bad Loans: Evidence from Italian Banks
By Marcello Bofondi and Tiziano Ropele
-
The Impact of the Sovereign Debt Crisis on the Activity of Italian Banks
By Ugo Albertazzi, Tiziano Ropele, ...
-
Non-Linear Dynamics in the Euro Area Demand for M1
By Alessandro Calza and Andrea Zaghini
-
The Financing of Italian Firms and the Credit Crunch: Findings and Exit Strategies
-
Attitudes, Personality Factors and Household Debt Decisions: A Study of Consumer Credit
By Stefano Cosma and Francesco Pattarin
-
The Sovereign Debt Crisis: The Impact on the Intermediation Model of Italian Banks