Supreme Court of the United Kingdom - To Be or Not To Be Jewish: The UK Supreme Court Answers the Question; Judgment of 16 December 2009, R v. the Governing Body of JFS, 2009 UKSC 15

European Constitutional Law Review, 6: 481–502, 2010

22 Pages Posted: 17 Oct 2010 Last revised: 21 Sep 2012

Susanna Mancini

University of Bologna School of Law; Johns Hopkins University (SAIS)

Date Written: October 16, 2010

Abstract

On 16 December 2009 the U.K. Supreme Court held a state-funded Jewish school ("Jewish Free School") to be guilty of discrimination based on ethnic origin in the way it operated its admissions policies. The school’s admission criteria were based on the traditional membership rule of Judaism, according to which to be Jewish one must be born of Jewish mother. The Court considered that the admission test was not religious in nature, but ethnic-based and instructed the school to establish a new test based on autonomous individual decisions and on the irrelevance of descent, i.e. on a basis compatible with Christian logic. In this paper I critically analyze this decision, concentrating my remarks on three issues, namely, the categorization of Jews in ethnic terms, the nature of the Jewish membership rule, and the justifiability of discriminatory conduct that is motivated by religion. I argue that the Court, by applying a concept of equality that implies a homogenization of behaviours and values, ends up restricting the room for diversity that is necessary for the preservation of a genuinely pluralistic society.

Keywords: Religious Freedom, ReligiousTolerance, Jewish Free School, Judaism, Christianity, Islam, Ethnic Discrimination; Racial Discrimination, Race Relation Act, Faith School, Halacha

Suggested Citation

Mancini, Susanna, Supreme Court of the United Kingdom - To Be or Not To Be Jewish: The UK Supreme Court Answers the Question; Judgment of 16 December 2009, R v. the Governing Body of JFS, 2009 UKSC 15 (October 16, 2010). European Constitutional Law Review, 6: 481–502, 2010. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1693127 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1693127

Susanna Mancini (Contact Author)

University of Bologna School of Law ( email )

Via Zamboni 22
Bologna, 40126
Italy

HOME PAGE: http://https://www.unibo.it/sitoweb/susanna.mancini/en

Johns Hopkins University (SAIS) ( email )

Via Belmeloro 11
Bologna
Italy

HOME PAGE: http://www.jhubc.it/OUR-FACULTY/profprofile.cfm/profid=175

Paper statistics

Downloads
236
Rank
105,361
Abstract Views
1,069