Improving Longevity and Mortality Risk Models with Common Stochastic Long-Run Trends

Abstract

Modeling mortality and longevity risk presents challenges because of the impact of improvements at different ages and the existence of common trends. Modeling cause of death mortality rates is even more challenging since trends and age effects are more diverse. Despite this, successfully modeling these mortality rates is critical to assessing risk for insurers issuing longevity risk products including life annuities. Longevity trends are often forecasted using a Lee-Carter model. A common stochastic trend determines age-based improvements. Other approaches fit an age-based parametric model with a time series or vector autoregression for the parameters. Vector Error Correction Models (VECM), developed recently in econometrics, include common stochastic long-run trends. This paper uses a stochastic parameter VECM form of the Heligman-Pollard model for mortality rates, estimated using data for circulatory disease deaths in the United States over a period of 50 years. The model is then compared with a version of the Lee-Carter model and a stochastic parameter ARIMA Heligman-Pollard model. The VECM approach proves to be an improvement over the Lee-Carter and ARIMA models as it includes common stochastic long-run trends.

Keywords: Mortality Trends, Heligman-Pollard Model, Lee-Carter Model, VAR, VECM

JEL Classification: C52, C32, J11, N30, G22, G23