Download this Paper Open PDF in Browser

The Dark Side of the Force: The Legacy of Justice Holmes for First Amendment Jurisprudence

64 Pages Posted: 19 Nov 2010 Last revised: 19 Aug 2012

Steven J. Heyman

Chicago-Kent College of Law - Illinois Institute of Technology

Date Written: February 24, 2011

Abstract

Modern First Amendment jurisprudence is deeply paradoxical. On one hand, freedom of speech is said to promote fundamental values such as individual self-fulfillment, democratic deliberation, and the search for truth. At the same time, however, many leading decisions protect speech that appears to undermine these values by attacking the dignity and personality of others or their status as full and equal members of the community. In this Article, I explore where this Jekyll-and-Hyde quality of First Amendment jurisprudence comes from. I argue that the American free speech tradition consists of two very different strands: a liberal humanist view that emphasizes the positive values promoted by free speech, and a darker vision that is rooted in the jurisprudence of Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes. Holmes understands free speech as part of a struggle for power between different social groups - a struggle that ultimately can be resolved only by force. After sketching the liberal humanist view, I trace the development of Holmes’s position, which is grounded in his Darwinian understanding of human life and in his deeper view that all phenomena in the universe are governed by force. Next, I evaluate the Holmesian approach and discuss its implications for a wide range of contemporary issues, from hate speech and pornography to the Citizens United decision on electoral advertising by corporations. I conclude that Holmes’s view does not provide an adequate rationale for free speech, and that it undermines the liberal humanist principles that should be regarded as central to the First Amendment.

Keywords: free speech, free expression, First Amendment, Holmes, Brandeis, liberalism, liberal humanism, hate speech, pornography, Citizens United, corporate speech, Darwin, Darwinism, Social Darwinism, force, dignity

JEL Classification: K10, K19

Suggested Citation

Heyman, Steven J., The Dark Side of the Force: The Legacy of Justice Holmes for First Amendment Jurisprudence (February 24, 2011). William & Mary Bill of Rights, Vol. 19, pp. 661-723, March 2011. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1710813

Steven J. Heyman (Contact Author)

Chicago-Kent College of Law - Illinois Institute of Technology ( email )

565 W. Adams St.
Chicago, IL 60661-3691
United States
312-906-5228 (Phone)
312-906-5280 (Fax)

Paper statistics

Downloads
208
Rank
123,742
Abstract Views
1,465