Governance in Córdoba’s Mixed Tribunal: A Study on Microphysics of Power

33 Pages Posted: 10 Jan 2011

See all articles by Santiago Abel Amietta

Santiago Abel Amietta

University of Manchester - School of Law; Universidad Nacional de Cordoba - Centro de Investigaciones Juridicas y Sociales

Date Written: November 23, 2010

Abstract

Córdoba is the first province of Argentina to adopt lay participation for the decision of criminal cases. Since 2005, a mixed tribunal of 8 lays and 3 judges decide some criminal cases by the rule of majority. Drawing on in-depth interviews with judges, other officials and jurors, this thesis explores this unique encounter of legal professionals and lays from the perspective of “microphysics of power” as put forward by Michel Foucault. The analysis first focuses on legal professionals’ perceptions of jurors and unveils how these perceptions construct jurors as a problem that needs to be governed. Secondly I discuss the tools of governance put into practice by legal professionals and the Judiciary to direct jurors’ conduct and argue that the interaction between lays and professionals is largely demarked by the mutual operation of power relations and knowledge. Next I look to jurors’ narratives to unravel their practices of self-governance and finally I trace the possibility of the emergence of resistant discourses by focusing on the narrative of a single juror. All in all this thesis constitutes an important departure from the previous body of work about lay participation in criminal justice by its theoretical approach and methodological advantages. It aims to make, by the theoretically informed analysis of relevant qualitative data, fruitful contributions both to the field of inquiries on jury trials and to more general discussions on how power in its myriad forms shapes subjectivities and governs conducts whilst circulates and is resisted against.

Keywords: Jury trials, Governmentality, Foucault, Power-knowledge, Mixed tribunal, Lay participation in criminal justice, Argentina

Suggested Citation

Amietta, Santiago Abel, Governance in Córdoba’s Mixed Tribunal: A Study on Microphysics of Power (November 23, 2010). Oñati Socio-Legal Series, Vol. 1, No. 1, 2011. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1735502

Santiago Abel Amietta (Contact Author)

University of Manchester - School of Law ( email )

Oxford Road
Manchester M13 9PL, M139PL
United Kingdom

Universidad Nacional de Cordoba - Centro de Investigaciones Juridicas y Sociales ( email )

Caseros 311, 1er. piso
Cordoba, 5006
Argentina

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
120
Abstract Views
811
rank
233,073
PlumX Metrics