19 Pages Posted: 18 Jan 2011 Last revised: 8 Mar 2011
Date Written: January 17, 2011
Drawing from Coase’s methodological lesson, this article discusses the specific case of knowledge, which was for a long time chiefly governed by exchange mechanisms lying outside the market, and has only recently been brought into the market. Its recent, heavy “colonization” by the property paradigm has progressively elicited criticism from commentators who, for various reasons, believe that the market can play only a limited role in pursuing efficiency in the knowledge domain. The article agrees with the enounced thesis and tries to provide an explanation of it that relates to the fact that in specific circumstances property-rights can produce distinct market failures that affect the social cost and can consequently prevent attainment of social welfare.
In particular, the arguments set forth here concern three distinct externalities that arise when enforcing a property rights system over knowledge. First, the existence of a property right may itself alter individual preferences and social norms, thus causing specific changes in individuals' behaviour. Second, the idiosyncratic nature of knowledge, as a collective and inherently indivisible entity, means that its full propertization can be expected to produce significant harm. Third, property rights can cause endogenous drifts in the market structure arising from the exclusive power granted to the right holder: though generally intended as a necessary mechanism for extracting a price from the consumer, in the knowledge domain property rights can become a device for extracting rents from the market.
Keywords: Property Rights, Knowledge, Invention, Indivisibility, Externalities, Efficiency
JEL Classification: D23, K11, O31, D62, O34
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Ramello, Giovanni Battista, Property Rights and Externalities: The Uneasy Case of Knowledge (January 17, 2011). European Journal of Law and Economics, Vol. 31, No. 1, 2011. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1742347