What is the Value of Peer Review – Some Sociotechnical Considerations

Second International Symposium on Peer Reviewing – ISPR 2010, Orlando, FL, June 29-July 2, 2010

6 Pages Posted: 2 Feb 2011 Last revised: 25 Jun 2014

See all articles by William P. Hall

William P. Hall

University of Melbourne - Melbourne School of Engineering; Kororoit Institute

Susu Nousala

Aalto University; University of Melbourne

Date Written: June 1, 2010

Abstract

Scientific and technical knowledge of the world grows through individual processes of speculation, making and documenting knowledge claims, the social processes of circulating and testing them, and the cyclic iteration of these processes to incrementally build on what is already known. Formal publication of claims in journals has been critical to circulating and critiquing new knowledge claims.

Editorial peer review supposedly justifies the costs of the publishing activities surrounding it. Yet publishing costs, largely paid by libraries, have become unsustainable. Also, the costs discourage many from publishing and limit access of others to what is published.

Today’s editorial peer review results from the exponential growth and specialization of the sciences in the second half of the 20th Century, but offers little genuine epistemic value. It may actually thwart the advancement of innovative and revolutionary research.

Following Popperian evolutionary epistemology, we consider the social and epistemological dynamics of editorial peer review. We also note that that the ever increasing sophistication of digital technologies extending our cognitive capacities provides a pathway to very substantially reduce the cost of publishing whilst at the same time increasing the transparency and value of genuine peer review.

Keywords: Organization Theory, Karl Popper, Evolutionary Epistemology, Internet Technology, Publishing

JEL Classification: O30, O34

Suggested Citation

Hall, William P. and Nousala, Susu, What is the Value of Peer Review – Some Sociotechnical Considerations (June 1, 2010). Second International Symposium on Peer Reviewing – ISPR 2010, Orlando, FL, June 29-July 2, 2010 , Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1752649

William P. Hall (Contact Author)

University of Melbourne - Melbourne School of Engineering ( email )

185 Pelham Street
Carlton, Victoria 3053
Australia

HOME PAGE: http://www.orgs-evolution-knowledge.net

Kororoit Institute ( email )

127 Power Street
St Albans, Vic. 3021
Australia

HOME PAGE: http://kororoit.org

Susu Nousala

Aalto University ( email )

P.O. Box 21210
Aalto, FI-00076
Finland

University of Melbourne ( email )

Parkville
Melbourne, 3000
Australia

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
70
Abstract Views
705
rank
365,597
PlumX Metrics